Lodge

3111 W Gulf Dr, Sanibel, FL

Anchoring Sanibel Island’s coastline since 1895, this beloved independent beachside retreat sits on 10 acres of pristine Gulf of Mexico frontage. Completely free of corporate resort structures, the property focuses on the simple, natural beauty of old Florida, featuring direct access to world-famous shelling beaches, a heated outdoor pool, and private beachfront cottages or suites. Guests can use complimentary paddleboards or dine at the acclaimed on-site restaurant overlooking the water.

Part of our guide to independent stays in Florida.